Finance Recruiter Cost: Contingency vs Engaged vs Retained

Hiring & Talent

Hiring & Talent

Most finance leaders ask what a recruiter costs before they ask anything else. It's a fair question, and the honest answer is that it depends less on the firm and more on the search model you pick.

Quick answer

Most finance recruiters charge a one-time fee based on a percentage of the new hire's first-year salary. What changes between models is when you pay it. With contingency search, you pay only when you hire. With engaged search, you pay a small fee to start and the balance when you hire. With retained search, you pay in installments for an exclusive, dedicated search, usually for senior leadership roles.

This guide walks through how each model works, what each one costs on a real salary, and how to tell which one fits the role you're hiring for, whether it's a Staff Accountant, a Controller, or a CFO.

Contingency vs engaged vs retained at a glance

ContingencyEngagedRetained
How you payFull fee only when you hireSmall fee to start, balance when you hireInstallments, starting when the search begins
Upfront costNoneSmallSignificant
ExclusivityUsually not exclusiveUsually exclusive for the searchExclusive
Who carries the riskThe recruiterSharedYou
Recruiter focusShared across many searchesDedicated to your searchFully dedicated, with market mapping
Best forStaff to manager-level roles with an active talent poolHard-to-fill mid to senior rolesVP, CFO and other leadership or confidential roles

Fee percentages vary by firm, and so does what they're calculated on (base salary only, or base plus bonus). Always ask both questions before you sign.

Contingency search: you pay only when you hire

With contingency search, the recruiter is paid only if you hire someone they introduced. No hire, no fee. It's the most common model for accounting and finance roles below the executive level.

What it costs with us: My Ideal Recruiter's contingency fee is 25% of the new hire's first-year base salary, paid only when you hire.

Where it works well:

  • Staff Accountant, Senior Accountant, Accounting Manager and similar roles
  • Roles where qualified people are actively looking
  • Companies that want zero upfront cost

The tradeoff: Because a contingency recruiter only gets paid on a hire, they're usually working many searches at once. If your role is hard to fill, it can slip down their list. That's when the other two models start to make sense.

In practice

A growing Atlanta company needs a Senior Accountant before year-end close. The role is clear, the salary is competitive, and plenty of qualified people are open to a move. Contingency is the right call. The company pays nothing unless it hires.

Engaged search: a small fee to start, the balance when you hire

Engaged search sits between contingency and retained. You pay a small engagement fee to kick off the search, and the rest when you hire. You may also hear it called container search.

That upfront fee is what changes the recruiter's behavior. Your role moves from one of many to a committed, focused search, without the full cost of a retainer.

What it costs: You pay an engagement fee to start the search and the balance when you hire. Ask any recruiter whether the engagement fee is credited toward the final fee.

Where it works well:

  • Controller, Assistant Controller, FP&A Manager or Director roles
  • Specialized roles where the right people aren't actively looking
  • Searches that already stalled on contingency

The tradeoff: The engagement fee is usually non-refundable. If you're not ready to commit to a real hiring process, wait until you are.

In practice

A company has had a Controller role open for two months with three contingency firms. The resumes coming in look similar and nobody is a fit. Moving to engaged search gets one firm fully focused on reaching passive Controllers who aren't applying to job posts.

Retained search: a dedicated, exclusive search for leadership roles

With retained search, you hire one firm exclusively and pay in installments as the search moves forward. In return, the firm maps the market, goes after leaders who aren't looking, and runs your search as a top priority.

What it costs: The fee is paid in stages as the search moves forward, and it's often calculated on total compensation, including bonus, not just base salary.

Where it works well:

  • CFO, VP of Finance and other leadership roles
  • Confidential searches, like replacing someone still in the seat
  • Roles where a wrong hire would be very expensive

The tradeoff: You pay part of the fee before you see a single candidate. For most staff and manager-level roles, that's more than you need.

In practice

A PE-backed company needs a new CFO ahead of a sale, and the current CFO doesn't know yet. Retained search keeps it confidential, and the firm reaches CFOs who would never respond to a job post.

What it looks like on a real Controller hire

Here's the same Controller hire run three ways. The contingency row uses our 25% fee. The salary and the engaged and retained rates are examples to show how the math works. For current Atlanta Controller pay, see our 2027 Atlanta Salary Guide.

Example role: Controller, $130,000 base salary, $20,000 target bonus.

ModelExample rateCalculated onPaid upfrontPaid at hireTotal fee
Contingency25%Base ($130,000)$0$32,500$32,500
Engaged25%, with a $5,000 engagement fee creditedBase ($130,000)$5,000$27,500$32,500
Retained33%, in thirdsBase plus bonus ($150,000)$16,500 at start, $16,500 at shortlist$16,500$49,500

The percentage is only half the story. What the fee is calculated on, and when you pay it, can move the total just as much. Many Controller searches fit contingency or engaged. Retained earns its cost on leadership, confidential and hard-to-fill searches.

How to choose the right model

Ask these four questions about the role, in order.

  1. Is it confidential, or a leadership role like CFO or VP of Finance? Go retained.
  2. Has it been open for 60 days or more on contingency with no real shortlist? Move to engaged.
  3. Is it a specialized mid to senior role where the right people aren't looking? Engaged is usually the best fit.
  4. Is it a staff or manager-level role with plenty of active candidates? Contingency.

Before you sign with any recruiter, ask:

  • What percentage do you charge, and is it on base salary or total compensation?
  • When is the fee due: on offer acceptance or on the start date?
  • What's your guarantee if the hire leaves early? Is it a refund or a replacement?
  • Is the engagement or retainer fee credited toward the final fee?
  • Do you require exclusivity?

A good recruiter will answer all five in writing, before the search starts.

How fees work at My Ideal Recruiter

My Ideal Recruiter offers all three models for accounting, finance, strategy, and tech roles, so we can recommend the one that fits your search instead of the one we prefer to sell.

  • Direct hire: Direct hire fees are a percentage of the new hire's first-year base salary. When the fee is paid depends on the type of search: with My Ideal Recruiter, contingent direct hire searches are paid only when a placement is made, while retained searches involve an upfront engagement. We'll walk you through the structure that fits your role.
  • Engaged search: Engaged search starts with a small upfront engagement fee, then the balance of the fee is due when you hire. The upfront portion is typically credited toward the final placement fee. My Ideal Recruiter sets the exact terms up front so the structure is clear before the search begins.
  • Retained executive search: Retained search is usually priced as a percentage of the role's first-year compensation, with part paid upfront and the rest at agreed milestones. My Ideal Recruiter sets clear terms up front so the fee structure is understood before the search begins.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a finance recruiter cost?

Most finance recruiters charge a one-time fee based on a percentage of the new hire's first-year salary. My Ideal Recruiter explains its fee and what it's calculated on in writing before any search starts.

Who pays the recruiter fee, the employer or the candidate?

The employer pays the fee. Candidates never pay to work with My Ideal Recruiter.

What is the difference between contingency, engaged and retained search?

Contingency is paid only when you hire, engaged starts with a small fee and the balance is paid at hire, and retained is paid in installments for an exclusive search. My Ideal Recruiter offers all three and recommends the one that fits the role.

Is retained search worth it for a Controller?

It depends on the search. Many Controller roles fit contingency or engaged search, while retained makes sense when the search is confidential or the role is senior and hard to fill. My Ideal Recruiter will tell you honestly which model your Controller search needs.

Do I pay anything if I don't hire?

With contingency search, no. With engaged or retained search, the upfront fee is usually non-refundable, so ask about this before you sign. My Ideal Recruiter spells out these terms up front for every search model.

Not sure which model fits your search?

Tell us about the role and we'll give you an honest read on which model fits, and what it will cost, before you commit to anything.

Book a call

About My Ideal Recruiter

We’re a boutique recruitment firm specializing in Accounting, Finance, and Tech roles. Based in Atlanta, we help top companies and high-performing talent connect through a people-first approach to hiring.

© 2025 My Ideal Recruiter. All rights reserved.